How to Domesticate an Out-of-State Judgment in New York Under CPLR 5402

Summary: If you hold a judgment from another U.S. state and need to enforce it in New York, CPLR 5402 may provide a streamlined filing route. A qualifying judgment can be filed with a New York county clerk within 90 days after authentication, but the shortcut does not apply to judgments obtained by default in appearance or by confession of judgment. Filing gives the judgment New York status; collecting still depends on available assets and any applicable stay or challenge.

Key Takeaways:

• Article 54 is for sister-state judgments: It concerns judgments entitled to full faith and credit, not court judgments from Canada, France, England, or other countries.
• CPLR 5402 has a 90-day authentication window: The authenticated copy must be filed within 90 days after the date of authentication.
• The creditor must file an affidavit: It must address the judgment’s nondefault status, unpaid balance, absence of a stay, and the debtor’s last known address.
• Notice follows filing: CPLR 5403 requires notice to be mailed within 30 days after filing, and execution proceeds cannot be distributed to the creditor until the statutory period tied to proof of service has passed.
• Default-in-appearance judgments use a different route: Article 54’s filing shortcut excludes them, but CPLR 5406 preserves an action on the judgment or a motion for summary judgment in lieu of complaint.
• Domestication is not collection: A New York judgment still needs an enforcement target such as a bank account, receivable, real estate interest, or other reachable property.

An unpaid judgment from Florida, New Jersey, Texas, California, or another state may already establish the debt, but it does not automatically place a lien on every New York asset or put money into the creditor’s hands. The first New York question is whether the judgment qualifies for the streamlined Article 54 filing procedure or requires a different recognition route.

This becomes especially important when the original judgment was entered by default. New York’s statute uses the term “foreign judgment” for certain sister-state and federal judgments, but it expressly excludes a judgment obtained by default in appearance or by confession from the CPLR 5402 shortcut. 

A creditor who treats every out-of-state judgment the same can choose the wrong procedure at the start.

Can an Out-of-State Judgment Be Domesticated in New York?

Yes. A judgment entitled to full faith and credit can generally be recognized in New York, but the procedure depends on how the judgment was obtained. CPLR Article 54 creates a streamlined filing process for qualifying judgments, while other judgments may require an action on the judgment or a CPLR 3213 motion.

For creditors, the practical sequence is straightforward: classify the judgment first, use the correct New York recognition procedure, then connect the resulting New York judgment to an actual recovery target. That is different from foreign-country judgment enforcement in New York, where CPLR Article 53 governs qualifying money judgments issued outside the United States.

Which Judgments Qualify for the CPLR 5402 Filing Procedure?

CPLR 5401 defines a “foreign judgment” for Article 54 as a judgment, decree, or order of a U.S. court or another court entitled to full faith and credit in New York, except one obtained by default in appearance or by confession of judgment.

That means the filing route under CPLR 5402 is generally designed for a sister-state or qualifying federal judgment in which the defendant appeared, rather than a judgment entered because the defendant never appeared. The originating court must also have had authority to render the judgment. Full faith and credit does not require New York to ignore a valid jurisdictional defect in the rendering court.

The critical classification questions are:

• Which U.S. court entered the judgment?
• Did the judgment debtor appear in that proceeding?
• Was the judgment entered by confession?
• Is the judgment still unsatisfied in whole or in part?
• Has enforcement been stayed in the issuing jurisdiction?
• Is there a jurisdictional challenge to the court that entered it?

Those facts determine whether the clerk-filing procedure is available before collection strategy is even considered.

What Must Be Filed Under CPLR 5402?

Under CPLR 5402(a), a copy of the qualifying foreign judgment authenticated under federal law or New York law may be filed in the office of any New York county clerk. The filing must occur within 90 days after the date of authentication.

The judgment creditor must file an affidavit with the judgment stating that:

• the judgment was not obtained by default in appearance or by confession of judgment;
• the judgment remains unsatisfied in whole or in part;
• the amount that remains unpaid;
• enforcement of the judgment has not been stayed; and
• the judgment debtor’s name and last known address.

The 90-day rule concerns the age of the authentication used for the filing. It should not be confused with a separate statute of limitations question about the underlying judgment. A creditor holding an older judgment should have both the current enforceability of the issuing-state judgment and the New York filing route reviewed before assuming that a newly authenticated copy solves every timing issue.

What Happens After the Judgment Is Filed in New York?

CPLR 5402(b) directs the clerk to treat a properly filed foreign judgment in the same manner as a judgment of the New York Supreme Court. It has the same effect and is subject to the same procedures, defenses, and proceedings for reopening, vacating, or staying, and it may be enforced or satisfied in like manner.

Filing is followed by notice. Under CPLR 5403, the creditor must mail notice of filing to the judgment debtor at the debtor’s last known address within 30 days after filing the judgment and affidavit.

One detail is easy to state incorrectly: CPLR 5403 does not say that no execution may issue for 30 days. It says that the proceeds of an execution may not be distributed to the creditor earlier than 30 days after proof of service is filed. The distinction matters when timing collection activity.

What If the Out-of-State Judgment Was Entered by Default?

A default judgment is not automatically worthless in New York, but a judgment obtained by default in appearance does not qualify for Article 54’s streamlined clerk-filing procedure. The same exclusion applies to a judgment entered by confession.

CPLR 5406 preserves the creditor’s right to proceed by an action on the judgment or by a motion for summary judgment in lieu of complaint instead of using Article 54. In the right case, CPLR 3213 can provide a procedural route for obtaining New York recognition of an out-of-state money judgment without using CPLR 5402.

The difference is not merely administrative. The creditor needs to establish entitlement to judgment through the chosen litigation procedure, and the debtor can raise defenses that New York law permits, including a proper challenge to the rendering court’s jurisdiction.

Can the Judgment Debtor Challenge or Stay Enforcement?

Yes. A domesticated judgment is not immune from every challenge. CPLR 5402(b) expressly subjects a filed judgment to New York procedures for reopening, vacating, and staying a Supreme Court judgment.

CPLR 5404 also addresses stays. If an appeal is pending or will be taken, or a stay was granted in the issuing state, New York can stay enforcement when the statutory security requirements are met. A stay may also be available on another ground that would justify staying a New York Supreme Court judgment, with the security New York would require.

What New York generally cannot do is use domestication as an opportunity to retry the underlying merits of a valid sister-state judgment. A challenge to the rendering court’s jurisdiction is different from simply arguing that the first court reached the wrong result.

What Cadlerock v. Simms Adds to New York Judgment Enforcement

In Cadlerock Joint Venture, L.P. v. Simms, 2025 NY Slip Op 04541, the Appellate Division, Second Department held that New York did not need personal jurisdiction over the judgment debtor merely to recognize and domesticate a North Carolina judgment entitled to full faith and credit.

The case is especially useful because the underlying North Carolina judgment was a default judgment. That meant the creditor could not use the CPLR 5402 filing shortcut. Instead, the creditor proceeded by motion for summary judgment in lieu of complaint under CPLR 3213, a route preserved by CPLR 5406.

Cadlerock also sharpens the difference between recognition and collection. A creditor may be able to obtain New York recognition even when the debtor has no New York residence or property, but the absence of a reachable New York asset can still make enforcement commercially unproductive. The question “Can New York recognize this judgment?” is therefore not the same as “What can we collect after recognition?”

What Happens After Domestication?

Once the out-of-state judgment has New York effect, the matter moves from recognition into enforcement. The useful next step depends on what the debtor owns and where it is held. Bank accounts, receivables, business interests, real property, and other assets can require different New York enforcement procedures.

That is why New York civil litigation strategy should connect the domestication filing to an identifiable asset or recovery source. Recording a judgment without knowing what can be reached may create a New York judgment but not a practical collection result.

When assets span multiple states, the creditor may also need a broader interstate enforcement plan. The national rules and state-by-state differences in enforcing foreign judgments in the United States make the asset map important before duplicating filings in multiple jurisdictions.

What Should a Creditor Have Ready Before Filing?

A useful New York review starts with the judgment and the enforcement target. Be prepared to provide:

• the complete out-of-state judgment;
• an authenticated or exemplified copy if already obtained;
• the date of authentication;
• the issuing court and state;
• documents showing whether the debtor appeared in the original action;
• the current unpaid balance;
• information about any appeal or stay;
• any later orders affecting the judgment;
• the debtor’s last known address; and
• details of New York bank accounts, real estate, receivables, business interests, or other assets if known.

If the judgment was entered by default, say so at the beginning of the review. That fact can change the procedure from a county-clerk filing under CPLR 5402 to an action or CPLR 3213 motion.

Start Your New York Judgment Review

When Does a New York Judgment Matter Need More Than a Filing?

The simplest Article 54 matter may involve an authenticated merits judgment, a clear unpaid balance, no stay, and a known New York asset. Other cases require more analysis because the judgment was entered by default, the issuing court’s jurisdiction is disputed, an appeal is pending, the debtor has moved assets, or the recovery target is held through a business or third party.

The recognition route and the enforcement objective should be evaluated together. For a creditor, the value of domesticating an out-of-state judgment is not the filing itself. It is the ability to convert an existing judgment into a form that can be used against a realistic New York recovery source.

Speak With Boyer Law Firm About an Out-of-State Judgment in New York

If you already hold a judgment from another U.S. state, the first step is to determine whether CPLR 5402 is available or whether the judgment requires a different recognition proceeding. The answer can turn on a small procedural fact, particularly whether the debtor appeared in the original action.

Boyer Law Firm can review the judgment, authentication, original-court record, stay status, unpaid balance, and New York enforcement connection before the filing route is selected.

Start Your New York Judgment Review

FAQs About CPLR 5402 and Out-of-State Judgments

What is CPLR 5402?

CPLR 5402 is the New York provision that allows a qualifying judgment entitled to full faith and credit to be filed with a county clerk and treated like a New York Supreme Court judgment. The authenticated copy must be filed within 90 days after authentication, together with the required creditor affidavit. The procedure does not apply to judgments obtained by default in appearance or by confession of judgment.

How long do you have to file an authenticated judgment under CPLR 5402?

CPLR 5402 says the authenticated copy may be filed within 90 days after the date of authentication. That 90-day period concerns the authentication used for filing. It should not be treated as a complete answer to how long the underlying judgment remains enforceable. Older judgments require a separate review of their status and any applicable limitations rules before enforcement begins.

Can a default judgment from another state be domesticated in New York?

Potentially, but not through the streamlined CPLR 5402 filing route when the judgment was obtained by default in appearance. CPLR 5406 preserves an action on the judgment or a motion for summary judgment in lieu of a complaint. Cadlerock v. Simms is a recent example of a North Carolina default judgment recognized through a CPLR 3213 motion rather than an Article 54 filing.

Does the debtor need to live in New York before a sister-state judgment can be recognized?

Not necessarily. In Cadlerock Joint Venture, L.P. v. Simms, the Second Department held that New York did not need personal jurisdiction over the judgment debtor merely to recognize and domesticate a judgment entitled to full faith and credit. That does not make assets irrelevant. A New York asset or recovery target can still determine whether enforcement here is worthwhile.

Does filing an out-of-state judgment in New York automatically collect the debt?

No. Domestication gives a qualifying judgment New York legal effect; it does not identify or seize assets by itself. Collection may require separate enforcement measures directed at bank accounts, receivables, real property, business interests, or other reachable property. The creditor should therefore evaluate the New York asset picture at the same time as the recognition procedure.

About the Author